|
Devonshire Capital
Bank of Ayudhya $540
million equity private placement
Extract from the Financial Intelligence Asia Magazine
(FIA), Summer 1999
Many investment banks and
fund management companies have been downsizing during the past two
years of economic turmoil in Asia and in some cases the decision
has been made to pull out lock, stock and barrel. While some of
the big, bulge bracket firms have decided the region does not warrant
the time or investment afforded to domestic markets, a lesser known,
smaller operation has stood firm in its commitment to Asia - Devonshire
Capital
Philip
Newson (right), CEO, and
Andrew Affleck,
Managing Director,
Devonshire Capital
A privately owned investment and merchant banking
organisation operating primarily in southeast Asia, Devonshire Capital
has been established since 1996 with branch offices in Kuala Lumpur
and Bangkok and representative offices in Hong Kong and New York.
The company's business scope includes direct investment, corporate
finance, fund management and corporate advisory services.
A usually media-shy company, Devonshire Capital
has found itself in the spotlight of late as a result of its successful
Bank of Ayudhya $540 million equity private placement - one of the
largest in Thailand's corporate history - at the beginning of June.
According to Devonshire's CEO, Philip Newson, the success of the
placement was not merely the result of the company's smooth distribution
and execution capabilities, but of years of building relationships
and assimilation with the local markets.
"The relationships we have established in
southeast Asia do not just happen overnight," asserts Newson.
"In a strange way, the Asian crisis has been of benefit to
us. When many firms were deciding to pull out of the region during
the crisis we stood firm in our commitment to our clients. Our constant
communication allowed us to understand their needs and structure
solutions accordingly."
Newson points out that this made all the difference.
"Although we are smaller in terms of human resources [than
the larger European and US investment banks] this has actually acted
to our advantage," he says. "I think many corporations
in Asia, currently undergoing similar restructuring processes, want
to know that you're tailor-making solutions to suit their needs,
not just pushing the many existing products you may have in the
shop."
An Interface for
Corporate Asia and International Institutional Investors
However, Devonshire's strength lies not only in
its relationships with corporations in local Asian markets but also
in its power of distribution to the international investment community.
The Bank of Ayudhya placement is proof of this. Devonshire was able
to secure the mandate and place the entire deal within 17 days of
commencement. Over 48 percent was sold to investors outside of Thailand
of which 36 percent was accounted for by European investors, 6 percent
by investors form the United States and 58 percent from Asian investors.
There was clear domestic support for Bank of Ayudhya, demonstrated
by the fact that 52 percent of the issue was taken by local investors.
Devonshire's Managing Director, Andrew Affleck,
attributes the speed of the deal to the professionalism of his sales
team and to the depth and quality of the company’s client base.
Affleck also stresses that the deal sold itself due to its simple
structure - an equity capital raising exercise was the ideal way
to entice foreign investors back into the market, offering considerable
potential upside on one of Thailand's most respected blue-chip banks.
"I have believed all along that when the time was right, Asia's
best managed, quality companies would once again be in favour with
foreign investors," he says. "That's exactly what we've
seen begin to occur in Thailand. The timing of the Bank of Ayudhya
placement was perfect. Here we had a top corporate issuer with a
story to tell and international investors were eager to listen."
From the Bank's perspective the exercise was a
tremendous success. Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Khun Krit
Ratanarak was impressed with Devonshire's execution and ability
to raise the bank's profile, ensuring the most efficient method
of raising capital. "We were pleased to work with Devonshire
on this placement," comments Khun Krit. "They proved to
us that the appetite [from international investors] for quality
companies in Thailand will always exist at the right price."
Henry Cheong, Chairman of Worldsec International
Limited in Hong Kong, international placement agent for part of
the placement, believes the strength of the managers lay in their
ability to discern the needs of the Bank and at the same time bring
together investors from all over the globe interested in the Asian
restructuring story. "It was extremely fulfilling to play a
role in the success of one of Thailand's largest equity private
placements to date," says Cheong. "However, in order to
place $540 million worth of stock coming off the back of the crisis
required a quality issuer, efficient pricing and precision of execution."
Devonshire's mission is to act as an interface
between local corporations in Asia and foreign institutional investors.
Its offices in Bangkok and Kuala Lumpur have been successful in
doing just that for the Thai and Malaysian markets respectively.
Philip Newson explains that this has largely been
due to management's understanding of the unique business cultures
of each country. "There are two fundamental requirements to
conducting business in Asia : integrity and discretion," he
states. "Integrity is a function of commitment and delivering
what you promise. Discretion is vital in Asia as markets in the
region all have their individual characteristics and sensitivities."
Tailor-made Solutions
The Bank of Ayudhya placement represents one deal
successfully completed in Thailand. However, Devonshire has used
the same principles to win business all over Asia, most notably
in Malaysia. Underlining the management's point that solving clients'
problems is more important than selling existing products is the
Patimas ADR program instigated by Devonshire and sponsored by the
Bank of New York.
A second-board Malaysian information technology
counter, Patimas's domestic plans to finance its expansion program
were put on hold when Malaysia introduced capital controls in 1997.
Even though the company's balance sheet was strong and its strategic
business partners included the likes of IBM, international investor
sentiment at the time dictated that all Malaysian companies were
'off-limits'. However, Patimas has managed to keep a good profile
with investors in the United States via the ADR programme set up
with help from Devonshire.
Devonshire's objective was to make certain Patimas
is in a position to access international markets as and when appropriate.
The solution, according to Affleck, was simple. "Patimas is
a quality second board counter in an industry with excellent growth
potential," he explains. "Affected in the short-term by
capital controls, our job was to ensure it would not suffer in the
long-term. With this in mind we persuaded the company to embark
on an ADR program with a view to possibly raising capital on Nasdaq
in the future, via a level two or level three program." Raymond
Yap, Patimas's Managing Director was pleased with the results. "We
managed to keep a decent profile with US investors at a time when
most other companies were simply ignored," recalls Yap. "We
were very grateful to Devonshire for finding the solution to a difficult
problem for us."
Into the New Millennium
This demonstration of commitment
to clients and the region for the future is part of Devonshire's
long-term strategy. "Where other firms saw the Asian crisis
as a signal to exit the market, we saw it as an opportunity."
reflects Newson. "Going forward, our business philosophy and
strategy remain unchanged. We will continue to promote quality companies
in Asia and to introduce them to the international institutional
investor community."
|